Friday, February 18, 2011
Activist Judges on Same-Sex Marriage, by Josh Goetz
opinion on the topic.
The mood of the lecture was developed through the rhetorical situation and the physical features that were present. Before the presentation the lights were dimmed and each person in the audience introduced themselves and their experience. The audience was then set as an educated group that Barclay was expected to woo. The room was very dark and the audience sent mixed messages. One woman was eating her lunch while he presented so in between his points crunching was heard. Other people in the audience were nodding after his points and occasionally would shoot a dirty look over to the oblivious woman eating. Barclay himself was wearing a suit as other men in the audience. He was clean cut and wearing a khaki colored suit and a dark red tie. The way he was dressed showed that he took this presentation seriously. After Barclay was finished with his PowerPoint he opened the floor up to questions. One man asked Barclay to further explain a theory using a theory that he had presented using the state of California as an example. Before the man had even finished his question Barclay was walking towards his computer and changing slides on the PowerPoint. His insincere actions showed disrespect to the man who he had been trying to convince. The woman finished her lunch and asked a question regarding a local issue and offered a way that she thought would be fitting to move the issue forward; he once again cut her off and blatantly denied her idea and substituted it with his own opinion. After his reaction to the two questions being posed, the audience seemed more hesitant to ask questions.
Barclay appealed to the ethos of the audience by his seeming professional and experience on the subject. The introduction of Barclay from a representative from the University of Denver and a little bit of background information tried to ease the audience into trusting him as a valid source. At the start of Barclay’s presentation he passed out a fifteen page article that he had written reporting on all the relevant cases on this topic. He said that he would be able to answer any questions on any particular event after his presentation. The forty five minute speech earned nods and questions from the audience on both specific examples and general theories. Barclay’s proposed that there were no activist judges for same-sex marriage. He did not blame this on the courts but the relationship between the legislature and the courts. He challenged this relationship as jeopardizing the efficiency and the legitimacy of the law making and enforcing system. The link between these two branches enables both sides to step out of the line of fire and bounce the responsibility of decisions back and forth.
Barclay offered an array of information, statistics, and analysis of old documents and past judicial examples to support his reasoning that there are no activist judges because they tend to reflect the legislative decisions. His use of statistics and specific examples helped to develop a stronger argument. Without strong background this argument is hard to create because it is so complex. The relationship between courts and the legislature is challenging to establish without analyzing multiple past cases. Barclay’s evidence supported his claim and he was able to better sway his audience. His examples were deeply imbedded in the knowledge of the situation and they were too complicated for me to follow and understand fully. Maybe since I was not his target audience the rest of the people he was trying to convince were more able to follow his ideas and his examples. I feel like more background on the topic at the beginning of his PowerPoint would have been a good investment to appeal to a broader audience. A slide or two could have easily caught me up on the topic while not boring those who are better versed on the topic.
The rhetorical situation was established through the amount and relevance of the cases being analyzed. This debate has been alive for forty-five years, and within the last fifteen years there has been a shift in the popular initiatives. There is a large possibility of appeal to pathos in this topic. Those who support same-sex marriage are usually very strong in their opinions. This is not an issue that people take lightly from either side. The lack of pathos in Barclay’s presentation severely decreased his effectiveness and was an area where he could have been much more persuasive. His presentation was strictly based on the court decisions and legislation on the topic. He used a specific slide that had every change in policy or important court case on same-sex marriage for the last fifty years. His examples were very impressive and thought provoking on his argument, though if he was to introduce an appeal to pathos his argument would be much stronger.
The introduction to the presentation set up the speaker as a person with a high level of expertise on the subject of same-sex marriage. His level of experience did not help him to relate the information to the entire audience effectively. Barclay finished the presentation on a negative note because of the way that he responded to his audience’s concerns and interests. He came across as just presenting evidence and did not take advantage of the possibility of appeals to pathos that could have greatly strengthened his argument.
Judicial Activism and Marriage, by Jessica Starr
I attended Scott Barclay’s discussion, Why aren't there activist judges on the issue of same-sex marriage?, based off of his research into judicial activism and legislation on Thursday, February 10th. Barclay addressed the issue of same-sex marriages and the lack of activist judges by using various types of rhetoric, mostly the pathos, ethos, and the inherent kairos of this issue. By using solid techniques while using an effective presentation method, Scott Barclay was able to appeal to his audience about his views and academic overview of the issue.
Barclay focused on addressing the various educational and interest backgrounds of his audience by using easy-to-understand language and presentation methods. The presenter was addressing the small voluntary audience in a university conference room. This choice of venue made sure that only persons associated with the University of Denver would come to the conference, and that a smaller audience would have more freedom in asking questions and providing insight into the topics of activist judges and same-sex marriage. As a person in the audience, I did not feel like I was just a ‘face in a large crowd’- I knew that I was a member in an audience whose opinions and views were appreciated.
The fifteen person audience was generally composed of staff and faculty of the University of Denver, with only two or three students attending. The majority of the faculty was in the social sciences and studies at the University of Denver, and may have had biases in affirmation of the topic. Students had lesser knowledge of the topics at hand, and were at a disadvantage at understanding all the research that the speaker provided. Scott Barclay was dressed in neutral tones (light tan suit with shirt), which didn’t give him power colors. He may have done this on purpose to not seem imposing but to educate his audience on the issue. The suit choice also made him look more like a lecturing professor, which added to his credibility as an academic.
Barclay was introduced in a short speech, introducing him as an academic speaker and a prominent researcher in social sciences issues. The speaker introduced his argument and research by introducing his background in education and by giving the audience his fifteen-page article, titled, In Search of Judicial Activism in the Same-Sex Marriage Cases: Sorting the Evidence from Courts, Legislatures, Initiatives, and Amendments. Scott Barclay’s research and education gave him ethos because he commanded a sense of knowledge and leadership in his topic. The audience trusted Barclay in his knowledge and him leading into the topic.
Scott Barclay also made use of a PowerPoint presentation while he was speaking, which would simplify and clarify points that the audience may have missed. The PowerPoint presentation also introduced visual elements into the discussion, which illustrated the constantly changing views of the public, legislation, and courts, which reflect the current kairos of the decision of same-sex marriage. The PowerPoint showed that as time has gone on, there has been more legislation and judgments in favor of same-sex marriage. As time goes on into today, we see the kairos of the situation come to a tipping point.
While the speaker presented about the lack of activist judges, he stayed stationary and off to a corner in the room, not coming towards the long table that filled the center of the room. Barclay would occasionally gesture with his hands, but would only move to change the slides of the PowerPoint and to recheck his points. This didn’t seem like a strong technique because the attention became more focused on the visual presentation of the PowerPoint than the speaker. This was only saved due to his imposing height and his strong Australian accent, which kept the attention of the audience.
When the presentation concluded, the general mood of the audience was of interest except for the students who had chosen to attend. The majority of Barclay’s arguments were based in social science knowledge, and for students such as myself, much of the background knowledge went over my head. I know the gist of the issue, but nothing of the activist judges and what exactly the roles they played in government. The staff and faculty that attended did ask questions pertaining to the clarification of some of his points, but none of the students asked questions. In order to improve his argument to audiences, Barclay should tailor his presentations to different types of audiences and educational backgrounds.