Showing posts with label oratory. Show all posts
Showing posts with label oratory. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 13, 2010

Lance Black Comes to Colorado

Lance Black Speaks to Colorado College Students
When the Academy Award winning screenwriter, Lance Black, took the stage at Colorado College to give a speech, the audience excitedly anticipated what they knew would be an captivating talk. Interestingly enough, few members of the audience actually knew what Black was there to talk about. Was he going to focus mainly on LGBT Rights, or would he talk mostly about his career in Hollywood? Black, who stated officially at the start of the speech that he hated speaking to large crowds, spoke about his life as a gay man in a conservative Texas town and his climb to the top of the Hollywood ladder. Speaking to a crowd of mainly students in a small liberal college, Black seemed at ease despite his own warning not to let his shaking and sweating distract from his words. This may have been because he knew his audience, consisting of many fans, was in tune with the message he was sending.
While his message contained one purpose, there was more than one exigence. One main exigence in his speech dealt with today being a critical moment for LGBT Rights despite their recent fade from the public eye. The black and white poster with Harvey Mlik leading a protest speaks to this exigence. Black explained that the reason he wrote the film “Milk” was because he wanted people to remember Harvey Milk and all that he did for LGBT rights in the seventies. He said that by forgetting Milk’s fight, we as a free nation are taking a step backwards when we have been poised, by activists like Milk, to go forwards.
Black also discussed how those naturally inclined to act on their beliefs, for example today’s leaders and the leaders of the new generation, are not doing so. The Obama poster mimicking Shepard Fairey’s iconic poster says, “Hope?” The poster effectively displays this idea because it is identifiable among the generation it is speaking to, my generation. The colors of the gay flag in the poster, along with what it says, send the message that there is little promise for more LGBT rights under the current government. In both cases, Black’s purpose was to convince his audience to act upon these exigences. After all, his young, active audience members who came to see him speak on a Friday night would be obvious candidates for leaders in the LGBT movement.
Black’s message targeted our generation. Both posters speak to the need for imminent action. Although our generation is, as a whole, politically charged and remarkably more open and accepting of sexual orientation, it may be that our generation is so dedicated to President Obama’s agenda that it disregards the LGBT movement. Black speaks out to this generation in order to call its attention to the LGBT rights. This generation seems naturally inclined to stand up in support of the LGBT agenda; however, the stimulus behind the LGBT movement has weakened in recent years. Engaging such a politically active generation is the best way to get the attention of Obama’s government, which has been so enthusiastically championed by our generation. Black aims to gather support from our generation as a way to direct the government’s attention to the LGBT issue. Black’s talk, and the audience’s support and enthusiasm for what he had to say made it clear that the LGBT movement will likely be the civil rights movement of this generation.

From Fear driven to Conscience driven

Wendell Potter, the former Public Relations Executive of the giant health insurance corporation Cigna, now frequently speaks out against the current health care system at different cities in the U.S., advocating for meaningful health care reform. On March 26, Potter came to Denver to give a speech at a local Christian church. The reason that Potter felt compelled to speak out was in part to the circumstance that the current health care system has driven insurers to pursue maximum profits for their Wall Street investors and because the collusion between insurance companies with the mass media, which has been misleading people about health care reform. Potter employed narrative storytelling to reveal some common tactics he saw applied by insurers to their policyholders when working in the health insurance industry. At the end of his speech, Potter emphasized the significance of rejecting the scare tactics, which tends to keep people in their comfort zone and prevent them from taking actions supporting health care reform. By revealing the sickness of current health care system and indicating the urgency of health care reform, he sincerely called upon his audience to stand up to call for governmental regulations and to take actions to stop the misbehaviors and corruption of insurers.

Potter gave several anecdotes that had impacted on his professional life, including a real story that prompted his decision to quit his high paid job as an executive of Public Relations at Cigna. He shared a girl’s tragedy handled by him that was caused by the insurer’s self-interest and profit driven character. Potter emphasized this moving story as his defining moment in his life, which led him to stand up against huge insurance companies with courage. In this real story, when a girl from California got cancer and needed help from her insurance company Cigna to pay for a liver transplant, Cigna denied her at first due to the cost, categorizing the surgical operation as experimental. However, following outraged expressed by people from the girl’s hometown of an organized protest, Cigna reluctantly changed its decision and agreed to pay for the cost. As the executive president of Public Relations at Cigna, Potter handled the case as instructed by his CEOs. Though running counter to his conscience, he followed the company’s policy and let the people know that the reason Cigna decided to help pay for the cost of the transfer was due to the company’s sympathy and kind heart. However, the girl passed away after battling with her cancer while waiting for the insurance company’s decision to pay for the operation. As the public spokesman for Cigna, Potter felt responsible for the girl’s death long after she passed away even while he continued Cigna’s charade.

Potter recalled travelling domestically and internationally in his company’s wasteful and extravagant private jets. All the while he realized that every dollar spent on the luxury could have been spent on patients saving lives. Logos and ethos in Potter’s message interact to produce coherence and consistency for the overall purpose of exhorting his audience.

Cigna is a representative of many profit-driven giant insurers; the girl’s premiums are one of thousands of hundreds premium dollars wasted on executives who pursue luxurious life style. Similarly, this tragedy is also a representative of common cases that insurance companies would frequently do to their policyholders who need their insurance companies to honor policies. The speaker chose this girl’s story as the representative to appeal for more sympathy from people’s common feelings for girls and is aimed to rhetorically gain empathy from his audience. Though the average age of his audience could have been a constraint on the rhetorical situation, Potter took advantage of this situation by letting his audience identify themselves as parents and grandparents that allows them to feel empathy for the unbearable lost of the girl’s family. As for the audience themselves, they are and will be at the age that requires trustful and dependable health insurance coverage. The girl’s story cruelly revealed the possible outcomes that would happen to them when in need of health insurance coverage. People logically assume that paying to have insurance will make them feel financially secure when emergencies happen. In contrast, when people revisit the girl’s situation, they pay to get nothing but mistrust towards insurers and unfairness.

After he shared this story, he expressed that he ran counter into his crisis of conscience and could not help crying when he mentioned that the girl died due to the lack of immediate medical treatment. He felt a call from his heart asking him to stop working for profit driven cooperatives but beginning speaking out against insurance companies that using unethical dirty tricks to their policyholders. By publicly revealing the tricks to against insurers as an insider, he advocates a change of the current health care system, which has led insurers to operate to maximize profits for their CEOs and shareholders. Knowing most of his audience is also both politically and socially advocating health care reform, he shared his defining moment that he quit his considerably high pay job and urged people to follow their hearts doing right things without fear.

By sharing his decision making at the turning point of his career life, Potter developed his character in his speech. The call he heard had given him courage not to fear about any outcomes. It was difficult to make such a decision that would lead him into mid-age crisis—having to take care of all family expenses—as well as endangering his life and his family’s safety. He created himself a courageous but not self-interest or greedy persona, of who overcame his fear of safety and walked away from his about 20 years career life and salary. In addition to this character, his rich experiences with the health care industry give him competence that greatly builds up his credibility in front of his audience. Standing up against to the health care system and speaking to his audience at a Christian church, he emphasized the call he heard that urged him to do something right. Though the religious beliefs of his audience could have been another constraint of his speech in this situation, once again, instead, he took an advantage of it by letting his audience feel that they have undeniable obligations responding to their god’s call that tells them not to fear about getting out of the comfort zone but to be on the same side of frontline with him.

Amanda Griffin: The Rhetorical Forgiveness of Wendell Potter

On Sunday March 28th, 2010 Wendell Potter gave a captivating speech at Central Presbyterian Church in Denver. He spoke about his experience as the head of Communications for Cigna Health Insurance. He focused his speech on the “tricks” he employed to generate a falsified spin on the insurance company; portraying them in a positive light. He gave a specific example of a young girl who was denied a liver transplant because it was deemed “experimental.” This young girl received considerable media attention making the insurance companies seem like “the bad guys.” Potter’s job was to cover up the story and make the young girl, whose ultimate fate was death, appear to be not the fault of the insurance company. Potter felt unbelievable guilt about his role in the tragedy, which ultimately caused him the leave the industry.

The roll that Potter played in the schemes of the insurance company upset the scales of justice for both his life and the life of many other people. His speech was a means of asking for forgiveness for his immorality. This allows the audience to serve as the ‘judge’ who determines his fate as resented or forgiven by tipping the scales in one direction or the other. His rhetoric forgiveness did not exemplify any misperception or tactics he had previously used. He painted a story of truth and honesty by providing details of events, taking responsibility for his actions, and even testifying against those who he allied with. This leaves the audience in charge of being sympathetic or opposed.

My three-dimensional representation is the scales of justice; depicting the impartial deliberation or “weighting” of two sides. The scale represents justice for the individual and portrays the right of society to decide the outcome based upon the unlawful wrongdoings of that person. One side of my scale represents the appalling actions of Wendell Potter by using the symbolic image of cards. As mentioned above Potter acted as the one who manipulated peoples perspective’s by leading them in a a false understanding - he was the “poker face” of the insurance companies who bluffed the truth. The other side of the scale represents forgiveness with a white dove. The white dove is a symbol of peace, as I believe Potter is trying to make peace with his actions while asking other people to do the same. Ultimately the audience is the judge of his actions and will be the determinant of whether the scales are balanced or not. Wrapped up along the base of the scale is text quoted from Potter's speech. The text focuses on the various arguments he made while explaining his actions. Some of the text includes a quote from Dante Alighieri, thoughts about the "system" of health insurance, and his actions to relieve the guilt he felt.